The Conversation (0)
iStock
Zigbee vs Z-Wave: What’s the difference and which is best for your smart home?
GearBrain explains the difference between the two most popular smart home wireless networks
When it comes to building a smart home, there are four main wireless technologies you need to know about. The first two are the well-known Wi-Fi and Bluetooth standards, of which you will already be aware. But the latter two are the comparatively unheard of Zigbee and Z-Wave.
These connect devices together wirelessly, but work in a different way to Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. This is because, instead of creating a direct connection between a hub or router and a device, Zigbee and Z-Wave use mesh networks, where data is sent from the hub to one device, then from that device to another, and another. This way, the data can reach devices which would usually be out of range of the hub, because it hops along a pathway created by each device acting as a repeater.
Read More:
Sengled Smart Hub, For Use with Sengled Smart Products, Compatible with Alexa, Google Assistant and Apple HomeKit, New Version
This data usually includes an instruction or a small piece of information. For example, it could be a command for a light to switch on, or a reading from a humidity sensor or flood monitor.
Zigbee and Z-Wave devices use very little power, and in some cases can last for years before their batteries need replacing. Devices which use these technologies include sensors (motion or water, for example), smart thermostats, door locks, switches, light bulbs, and smart plugs. They can be controlled by compatible Zigbee and/or Z-Wave hubs, like the Samsung SmartThings Hub or Amazon Echo Plus.
Zigbee is an open standard controlled by the Zigbee Alliance, established in 2002, and was originally created for commercial use before transitioning to the smart home. Meanwhile, Z-Wave was first developed by Danish company Zensys in 2001. Created specifically for the smart home, Z-Wave was sold to Sigma Designs in 2009, which then sold it to Silicon Labs in 2018 for $240 million.
What is a mesh network?
iStock
Mesh networks can cover an area (your home and garden, for example) more thoroughly than a Wi-Fi network. This is because a Wi-Fi network only sends data to and from a single hub, your router, and so devices placed further away have a weaker signal, which can cause connection problems. Owners of old houses with thick walls will also be aware of the limitations of Wi-Fi, when a router struggles to make its signal heard several rooms away, potentially leaving entire parts of a home out of range.
A mesh network overcomes this by taking a signal from the hub (the signal could be a light bulb being asked to switch on, for example) and relays this message via other devices in the network. This way, an instruction to turn the light on at the other end of the house still gets there, because it has been relayed by several other Zigbee or Z-Wave devices along the way.
What all this means is that smart home devices can talk clearly to each other throughout your home, and the more devices you install the better the network's coverage will be.
A major difference between how Zigbee and Z-Wave operate their mesh networks is that Z-Wave allows a signal or piece of data to be relayed four times across the network, while for Zigbee there is no limit.
The technical differences between Zigbee and Z-Wave
Although Zigbee and Z-Wave work in a similar way, sending messages to smart home devices over a mesh network, some of their capabilities differ. For example, Zigbee uses the 915 MHz and 2.4GHz radio frequencies, and you may recognize the latter as it is shared with Wi-Fi. In theory, this can cause interference issues in homes with a large number of Zigbee and Wi-Fi devices all fighting to be heard in the same space.
While this could be a concern for a shared workspace full of smart lights and customer phones and laptops all fighting over the 2.4GHz band, in a regular home interference like this shouldn't be seen as a deal-breaker for Zigbee.
Z-Wave doesn't suffer from Wi-Fi interference because it operates at the lower (and less congested) 800-900MHz frequency range.
Other differences include the amount of data each technology can transfer at once. Zigbee wins this one, offering data transfer speeds of between 40 and 250 kilobytes per second, compared to Z-Wave's 10-100kbps.
Although this is technically a victory, these speeds are still incredibly slow compared to Wi-Fi and cellular connections, which are generally measured in mbps, with 1mb being 1,000kb. The slow speeds of Zigbee and Z-Wave doesn't really matter, however, as they are only used to transmit very small amounts of data, like instructions for a device to perform an action, or readings from a sensor.
Samsung GP-U999SJVLGDA 3rd Generation SmartThings Hub, White
More meaningfully, Zigbee also wins when it comes to how many devices (or 'nodes') you can have connected to the same mesh network at once - 65,000, compared to Z-Wave's limit of 232 devices. In reality, it is unlikely that your smart home will have more than 232 devices in it, but if you happen to have a mansion filled with smart lights in every room, then you might want to use a Zigbee lighting product instead.
The technologies also differ when it comes to how far each device can transmit data. Zigbee's range falls between 33 and 66 feet, while Z-Wave is 100 feet. However, both of these figures depend on where the devices are, if walls are nearby, how thick the walls are, and various other factors, just as with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. But, given the mesh networking we explained earlier, it is highly likely that another smart devices is just a few feet away and able to repeat the signal before it falls out of range.
Finally, both technologies use the same AES-128 encryption to keep your smart home safe - especially important when using devices like smart door locks and motion sensors for alarm systems.
Which products work with Zigbee?
Some of the biggest and most well-known families of smart home devices work with Zigbee, like Philips Hue lights, the Samsung SmartThings system of hubs and sensors, and LG's new ThinQ smart home portfolio. Others include:
- Philips Hue
- Ikea Tradfri
- Samsung SmartThings
- LG ThinQ
- GE Appliances
- Belkin WeMo link
- Sengled lights
- ADT Security Hub
- Somy blinds
- Somfy window blind motors
- Honeywell smart thermostats
- Yale smart locks
Which products would with Z-Wave?
Devices which use Z-Wave include:
- August smart locks
- Schlage smart locks
- Samsung SmartThings
- ADT Security Hub
- Yale smart locks
- Somfy
- Kwikset smart locks
- Ring doorbells
- Fibaro water leak detector
- GE Appliances
- LG Thinq
- Aeotec water, door and window sensors
- First Alert smoke alarm
- GoControl lights and wall switches
Echo (2nd Generation) - Smart speaker with Alexa and Dolby processing - Limited Edition Walnut Finish
Can I use Zigbee and Z-Wave devices together in my smart home?
Yes. An important thing to remember when building your smart home is that a wide range of devices work with both Zigbee and Z-Wave, so you won't find yourself tied to one technology or the other. For example, hubs by Wink and Samsung SmartThings work with both standards, and so too do Honeywell thermostats, Yale smart locks, products by GE Appliances, and the LG ThinQ ecosystem.
It is also worth bearing in mind that Zigbee and Z-Wave devices can play nice in the same smart home, even if they don't talk to each other. For example, Philips Hue smart lights use Zigbee, bu they also connect to the Hue Bridge, which then hooks up to your Wi-Fi router. That way, you can control the bulbs directly from a Zigbee hub, or from a Wi-Fi connected smart speaker or display from the Amazon Echo or Google Home/Nest product lines.
If you plan to fill your home with a lot of smart devices, then a hub which talks to everything - like the Samsung SmartThings Hub - is a safe bet, as this caters for both Zigbee and Z-Wave.
But, with an increasing number of smart home products working with Alexa, Google Assistant and Siri, the way you build your smart home can be more flexible than ever.
Finally, while the first and second-generation Amazon Echo Plus have Zigbee built in (unlike all other Amazon and Google/Nest smart speakers), this isn't quite what it seems. Yes, the Echo Plus can directly control devices like Hue bulbs without needing the Hub Bridge hub, but functionality is limited.
From Your Site Articles
- Z-Wave Alliance Reaches 4000 Certified Devices and Growing - Gearbrain ›
- Yale Assure Lock 2 with Z-Wave: Now Available as a Bundle - Gearbrain ›
- Wi-Fi repeater versus Wi-Fi extender, What's the difference - Gearbrain ›
Related Articles Around the Web
GearBrain Compatibility Find Engine
A pioneering recommendation platform where you can research,
discover, buy, and learn how to connect and optimize smart devices.
Join our community! Ask and answer questions about smart devices and save yours in My Gear.
